Found February 19, 2012 on Pirates Prospects:

He's smiling about his potential extension value with the Pirates

This past week, Matt Swartz published a 2 part series of articles at Fangraphs that examined historical WAR value assumptions and what the actual numbers were.  It is a fantastic 2-parter, especially the second part that I linked.  It’s the kind of article that you really need to read, ponder for a minute or two, and then re-read it again to process the info.

To streamline the article, Swartz feels that the $/WAR has actually been undervalued historically.  He shows the WAR values accumulated by free agents and what the $/WAR is for each year, plus the $/WAR if you factor in the cost of the compensatory picks associated with signing those free agents as well.

Swartz’s conclusion that WAR has been undervalued actually gave me pause, because I’ve felt that in recent years it has actually been overvalued.  But his numbers and methodology are sound, so I have to change my way of thinking and start to accept these new numbers.  Swartz feels that the $/WAR for 2012 is actually $6.3 million if you include draft picks.  He allows a 9.4% reduction if you exclude draft pick compensation, which I would like to do as I feel the new CBA is going to severely limit how many free agents get arbitration offers from their old teams (a team has to make a $12.6M qualifying offer), so that gives a number of $5.7M/win.

One of the other interesting nuggets from the Swartz article is his breakdown of how free agents performed from 2007 to 2011 based on the tier of their average annual value: greater than $15M, between $10M and $15M, $5M to $10M, and less than $5M.  His research shows that players in the wobbly middle class of $10M to $15M actually performed the least effectively, needing $6.5M/win.  The best value?  The free agents in the less than $5M category are paid only $3.6M/win.

Hopefully this bodes well for Erik Bedard ($4.5M) and Rod Barajas ($4M).  Clint Barmes ($5.25M average value) just misses this bargain bin category.  Using the $5.7M/WAR  figure for 2012, you can see that all of these players, plus A.J. Burnett at $5M in 2012, only need to provide 1 WAR each to justify their contracts this year.

But how will this new value affect future contract extensions for the Pirates, specifically Andrew McCutchen?  Back in December, Tim examined the potential value of an extension for McCutchen.  At that time, Tim felt that 6 years/$51M was a fair value for McCutchen using Justin Upton’s contract as a baseline.  However, historically we have used $5M/WAR here at Pirates Prospects.

The other issue, and probably the one that the Pirates and McCutchen’s agent are wrestling with, is what is McCutchen’s ultimate ceiling.  In 2011, McCutchen tantalizingly produced 5.7 WAR, but you were left feeling that he had another gear not fully being used.  If we use 5.7 WAR as the baseline for 2012 (his age-25 season) and the $5.7M/WAR figure, McCutchen’s value would be $32.49M.  Considering that he will be paid an estimated $520,000 in 2012, his surplus value would be just under $32M.

Let’s take a look at what McCutchen’s potential next 6 years could look like, with a 5% escalation on WAR per year and upgrading Justin Upton’s existing contract:

Year Age $/WAR WAR Value Est. Salary Surplus Value 2012 25 5.7 5.7 $32.49 $0.52 $31.97 2013 26 6 6 $36.00 $5.00 $31.00 2014 27 6.3 6.5 $40.95 $7.50 $33.45 2015 28 6.6 6.5 $42.90 $11.00 $31.90 2016 29 6.9 6.5 $44.85 $16.00 $28.85 2017 30 7.3 6 $43.80 $16.00 $27.80

That totals up to 6 years/$56M and buys out the first 2 years of free agency for the Pirates.  You can also see that the Pirates have immense surplus value all throughout the duration of this assumed deal.  Even if you add in a $2M signing bonus for McCutchen and bring the deal to $58M, it is still a bargain for what McCutchen would bring to the franchise.

I would still consider a 5 year deal in the low $40M range as a compromise if McCutchen did not want to give up 2 free agency years.  At no point would I just buy out his arbitration years, as there is no benefit to the team other than providing cost certainty.


A Change to the Backup Infielder Competition

It looks like a good time to buy stock in Anderson Hernandez.  The Pirates’ decision to place Rule 5 pick Gustavo Nunez on the 60-day disabled list greatly narrows the competition for utility infielder spots.  They have a lot of players available to compete for bench spots, but many, such as Nick Evans and Jake Fox, are strictly corner players.  Somebody has to backup Clint...

Pirates 5x5 2012 Prospect Rankings

The top of the Pirates prospect rankings is dominated by starting pitchers and outfielders. A trio of each vie for collectively cracking the top five. The three starters have as much upside as any group of triplets in baseball. Top 5 fantasy prospects 1- Jameson Taillon, SP Taillon ranks behind Cole on most prospect lists, and usually, I'd go with the crowd. This...

2012 Pirates Draft Prospects Rundown: 2/20

The first weekend of the 2012 NCAA Division I season is in the books, giving us our first look at some of the top 2012 draft prospects. A few of the top guys got off to great starts, with the top performer being Victor Roache. Roache went 4-for-10 at the plate in his opening weekend, homering twice. The outfielder hit a Division I leading 30 home runs in 2011, and started his 2012...

Morton Ahead of Schedule

BRADENTON — Opening day continues to look promising for right-hander Charlie Morton. After undergoing offseason left hip surgery to repair a labrum tear in mid-October, the 28-year-old looks to be ahead of the six months recovery time. “Everything’s in a good place for Charlie, everything’s in a good place,” Pirates Manager Clint Hurdle said. “He’s continued to knockdown...

2012 Draft Bonus Pools Are Set

Jim Callis of Baseball America has announced that the bonus pools for the 2012 MLB draft are set. The only player who could impact the potential bonuses would be Derrek Lee, who is expected to either retire, or sign a minor league deal. Neither option would generate a compensation pick for the Pittsburgh Pirates. The bonus pool for the Pirates is $6,563,500. That’s the 16th biggest...

MLB Opinion: Pirates Make Mistake with Burnett Deal

The Pittsburgh Pirates made a mistake trading for enigmatic right hander A.J. Burnett and committing $13 million in salary to him over two seasons. While the Bucco’s didn’t give much up in the two prospects that they sent to New York, it still seems like too big of a financial risk for a guy that you just do not know what to expect from. The 35 year old has not had a winning...

Tim Wakefield and Former Pirates Pitchers

With Tim Wakefield announcing his retirement I thought I’d go through the unfortunate list for Pirates fans, of pitchers with the most wins after leaving the Pittsburgh Pirates, just to show where he ranks on that list. I included 11 players just to show the top 10 while he was with the Pirates, as all the other players on the list were retired prior to him leaving Pittsburgh....

A quick note on the 2012 Annual

The Pirates placed shortstop Gustavo Nunez on the 60-day disabled list this morning, making room for newly-acquired A.J. Burnett on the 40-man roster. With that roster move, the Pirates Prospects 2012 Annual was finalized and will soon be off to the publisher. I wanted to take a moment and thank all of you who have purchased the Annual or plan to do so in the future. I devoted a...

This Date in Pirates History: February 18

Seven former Pittsburgh Pirates players born on this date and we start with the man who pitched for the last two World Series teams in Pirates history. Bruce Kison(1950) was a 14th round draft pick of the Pirates in the 1968 amateur draft. He shot through the minors out of high school, going 30-9 over his two full and two partial seasons. Prior to being called up by the Pirates in...

Day Two of Spring Training

Good morning from Pirate City. I’ll be updating this blog throughout the day with news and notes, but be sure to check the main site for the full stories. — Earlier this morning, the Pirates placed infielder Gustavo Nunez on the 60-day disabled list with a right ankle injury. The move opened up a spot on the 40-man for right-hander A.J. Burnett. — And speaking of A.J. Burnett...

Paul McCartney Sings To Pedro Alvarez

Paul McCartney's Yesterday was voted to be the best pop song of all time by Rolling Stone. The line "Yesterday... love was such an easy game to play. Now I need a place to hide away. Oh, I believe in yesterday." can be applied to baseball. There are dozens of guys that played the game with such ease one year, then fell flat on their face the next, and I would guess...

Pirates Prospects on ESPN 970 Today

I will be on ESPN 970 today at 6:20 PM with Greg Linnelli, talking the A.J. Burnett trade and other Pittsburgh Pirates related topics. You can listen live on ESPN 970 AM in Pittsburgh, or online by going here.

Mac Pack gains another member in McLouth

Nate McLouth checked into camp -- tanned, ripped, ready to go -- and was promptly welcomed to the club. To the Pirates? No. The outfielder received an immediate initiation into the Mac Pack.

Pirates 2012 ... Position Battles

First base After Derrek Lee opted for free agency, the Pirates appeared resolved to platoon the position internally.

Pedro Alvarez and Pirate's starting rotation would seem to be most critical to 2012

BRADENTON, Fla. Neil Walker had a bird's-eye view. Walker played in 159 games last year, meaning he participated in the middling early portion of the season, the improvement in June, the division-leading play in July, the 10-game losing streak that began in August and the struggle to the finish line in September.
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.