Should Phillies Trade Jimmy Rollins?

Ok this isnt a rumor ive heard, this is just straight from my thought bank. There is some quality pitchers that can be traded for, that we could use in the rotation, to set us off. Now, ive watched Jimmy Rollins his entire career as a phillie, and i never been sold on him. Last year was a hell of a season, and lets face it, he wont have another or close to it. What im thinking is, trade him to the AL while his stock is high. Hes struggling this year, the phillies won, and are winning without him. He might be our lead off guy, but Shane Victorino could be also. Yeah hes a great shortstop, but Eric Bruntlett has show some flash there. Sometimes you have to give to get, and i think the phillies bats are able to lose Rollins. But i think our rotation would be dynamite with the names ive heard being thrown around. Now C.C. Sabathia we have no chance. But A.J. Burnett, who is at the last year of his deal, or Aaron Cook who is being dangled, who is having a great season in Colorado, Zach Grienke in KC, or we could get back on of our old arms, theres 2 i heard is being used as trade bait there in Texas, Kevin Milwood, and Vincente Padilla. Could be a chance too Randy Wolf becomes available. I could see Pat Gillick making a move like this, hes retiring at the end of the year, and i think the way the team is going, he might just make that one big move to push the phils over that hump, and get to the world series.

Vote this post up or down: 

53 Comments On: "Should Phillies Trade Jimmy Rollins?"

 
i disagree with this one wholeheartedly.

i agree to disagree
why trade this guy? he's great, he's made for Philly

NNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!
Wurth trade Wurth.

my trade bait list:

carlos ruiz
jason werth
ryan howard

please for the love of god not jimmy

Howard a Ruiz may be, no way Jason Werth or Jimmy Rollins!

I agree. But I'd move Rollins for SS Kahlil Greene, Greg Maddux, and a minor leaguer.

really, greene isnt very good, maddux is just a quality pitch\er nowadays and a minor leaguer may never make pros.

mom, i love my phils... but we need pitching to put us over that hump. if we added one more good quality starter, we will be set. werth, ruiz wont get that for us. howard and rollins could. i dont want howard gone, but rollins, i just dont see him doing what he did last year. the kid is letting the mvp get to his head. he doesnt even hustle out the fly balls. hes been injured and in a slump, and yet were having one of our best years as far as i can remember. we dont need him to win. we need pitching

I agree about the pitching, but Rollins is and has been my fav player for years. So your post is toying with my emotion. Hey, I'm a fan of any post that makes me think, even if I don't agree with it.
I have to say that if Werth has a "decent rest of this season", I believe he'll be gone next year.

ooops :( im sowwy!!!!! i dont mean to be soundin like im hatin on him... i guess it may be his sunglasses lol i dont know... but, i got to give him props for wearing his socks old school style when he wears the old school phillies uni

Can't trade Jimmy, he's a clubhouse leader, sparks the offense, and is a needed member of the Phils if they are to defend the NL East crown.

why do we need that when we have all that in chase utley? rollins is a one year wonder... never liked him... just wait and see...

one year wonder? what are you talking about? jimmy is an incredible SS. perfect middle infielder.

http://www.sportsline.com/mlb/players/playerpage/132668

Tommy, you might want to delete this whole post and move on, you are just making things worse!

I'm not sure what Rollins' contract situation looks like but I'm not sure this is a good move. He definitely doesn't have the OBP I would look for from a leadoff hitter but SS has been a semi-weak position over the past few years so I don't think he should go anywhere.

TRADE ROLLINS??????? Are you crazy ?? Ruiz .... Howard...... maybe. Let's wait till mid season before we put the horse before the cart!!!!!!!! Kendrick will improve, Hamels is god.... and Myers looks to be turning the corner, and getting back on track. plus moyer. We need solid 5 hole pitcher. ruiz and burrel could get us that and more. IF IT COMES TO THAT! ! ! ! Let's give it till mid season ....

Why the hell would we Trade Jimmy? I damn sure disagree. You must have been really bored to post such hogwash.

Ok yea this is sure genius tommy. Lets trade JIMMY ROLLINS for KEVIN MILLWODD or VINCENTE PADILLA?????? You must be ABSOLUTELY INSANE. And this is BY FAR the most ridiculous thing Ive ever read on yardbarker(including Eagles WR rumors) and THATS saying something. I would seriously delete this while you can, youre losing any bit of credibility or sense that you may have previously had. WOW

i dont want vincente padilla or kevin millwood, i was throwing out names that could be available. id rather have AJ Burnett or Aaron Cook.

the upgrade from Adam Eaton to Aaron Cook is not worth the downgrade from Jimmy Rollins to Eric Bruntlett. Like I said, delete the post and get on with your life.

im taking the shots like a man... it was just a thought... i love how fired up philly fans get lol...

You can make a case for trading Ryan Howard. You can make a case for trading Pat Burrell. But trading the heart and soul of the team is just plain stupid.

the heart and soul of the team is utley, howard and hamels. i just want a championship, and even though kendrick and eaton has been pretty decent, its not going to win us the world series.

J-Roll is the true leader in the clubhouse. Utley is great, but he is one of those "lead by examples" kind of guys. Howard and Hamels are not really leaders at all, just good players.

jamie moyer is a leader too... i didnt think sp many people would get mad over this. that wasnt my intention. i just had a thought and i blogged it. i do that on occasion. doesnt meant i want to have him traded personally. yeah he isnt my fav philly, he plays hard, but ive seen it during the year and during spring training, hes taking it easy this year. maybe charlie finally woke him up, cuz he did get that home run for us after his ass got sat

You have never been a fan of his and he was a one year wonder. I can not believe I was reading that. Sure hes struggling a little right now, but he is for sure the heart and soul of this team. Just watch the division clinching game only from last year in the last game against the Nats. He was the SOLE reason we won that game. He completely manufactured three of the runs in that game, Single, stole second, stole third, scored on sac fly. Double, stole third and scored on ground ball I think, and the icing on top of the cake was his record breaking triple in the 8th inning. The guy was an all-star before he was the MVP, and if he had a little more name recognition in the past he would be a multiple Gold Glove winner.

ITS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN! IT WAS ONLY A THOUGHT! CHILL THE F OUT PEEPS!!!! ID HATE TO SEE ROLLINS GO, BUT ID RATHER GIVE UP ROLLINS RIGHT NOW THAN HOWARD OR BURRELL!!! im just saying, if the phillies made that decision id be fine with it. I CAN SEE IF YOU GUYS FREAKED OUT IF I SAID TRADE CHASE UTLEY! christ, am i the only person here not entitiled to my opinion? ive seen worse stuff put up here and im getting crucified... we'll see at the end of the year, when pitching doesnt hold up in the playoffs AGAIN. SHORT STOPS DONT BRING CHAMPIONSHIPS! IT DIDNT LAST YEAR DID IT?

You'd rather trade Rollins than Burrell? You're a lost cause

you're getting crusified because you're an idiot

yeah, maybe lol

Why on earth would you get rid of J-Roll?!?! That might be the worst idea I've heard in 5 years. If you're looking to trade a big name for a pitcher...why not Ryan Howard. He strikes out WAY too much and there is really no chance the Phils give him any deal that would remotely resemble Utley's or J-Rolls.
AND, if you're looking to ship someone to the AL wouldn't you think it would be a Pat Burrel or Ryan Howard to move to the DL purely based on their fielding abilities vs. their bats?

Dude you're an idiot...your thought bank is BANKRUPT. Jimmy is the heart and soul of this team, the defending National League MVP, and a potential 30/30 guy who can hit for a .300 avg. every year. Oh and he plays some dammmn good D. Not sure if you noticed or not but the Phils win when Kendrick pitches and Eaton has been pretty darn good in the 5 spot. Ya don't mess with a good thing plain and simple.

what has he done for us lately? get injured? is in a slump... doesnt hustle out the fly balls? the mvp title has gotten to his head and he aint going to ever have a season like last year. we were winning without him on the DL, were winning with him in a slump... we dont need him. I rather have pitching

This year was the first time in his career he has gone out for an extended period of times...remember the consecutive start streak he had before injuring himself while trying to make plays on the basepath? Jimmy is the heart and soul...Chase and Hamels put up numbers but are not clubhouse leaders, Stevie Wonder could see that.

and you opinions are welcomed just like mine are, dont be an idiot yourself and start insulting people. if you dont like what others think, stay off of here. that was uncalled for. grow up.

Actually he's never reached .300 over the course of an entire season but that's neither here nor there I suppose.

1. keyword = potential

2. .289, .290, .296 are close enough

Tommy, this is quite possibly the most absurd thing i have ever heard from any philadelphia fan, ever!!! what are you going to trade him for??? how would you ever get equal value? bruntlett as an everyday player, come on man. he cant even sniff jimmy's jock. off year, the guy has been hurt and wait until august and sept. and then tell me the cat is still having an off year. CLUTCH CLUTCH CLUTCH CLUTCH CLUTCH! and what would you think that would do to the fanbase. no way. you are a moron and need to step in front of a bus, if not, i will gladly push you to put you out of your misery.

maybe i should take my opinion to 610 wip lol... it is a crazy thought... but thats all it was... i didnt think id piss the world off

its funny how u retards are saying this from a 3dbl performance no hr by howard...I would not give any active players on this phillies roster...right now they have DEPTH and very good players and very good role players, dobbs, coste etc...Our O obviously is fine and our pitching has been outstanding over the last 5 to 6 games but i wouldnt think twice for getting another SP b4 the deadline...I've heard Sabthia might be traded for 3 top prospects and im sure we could get some 1 right out there that might help our team by not giving away any 1 big.
Rollins made a critical hit in yesterdays game against atlanta..Just even thinking about trading some 1 on this O even though our SP's arent great is absolutley ridiculous...But id think about trading a few prospects for a solid starter...

Yeah i think i replied to the wrong post lol peace

hell NAW the phils shouldnt trade jimmy rollins

Are you kidding me? Let's try and see how the hell this team would do without Jimmy.

I don't think one starter puts this franchise automatically in the NL Championship series. Werth can't be traded because he's got to be our backup centerfielder for games that Victorino misses. I don't know enough about the farm teams to know what we can bring up.

After reading ridiculous/non story posts that so often appear on this site, I normally choose to ignore these people who are simply looking for a couple clicks but dude, this post is by far the stupidest I've read (any let's not forget our daily Roy Williams, Ocho-Cinco, Fitz stories we've had). Jimmy IS the heart and soul of this team. Utley is great, amazing and anything else postive I could say but NOT a vocal leader....at least yet. Jimmy is your spark, your leader, your team. Dude, I'm not even coming back to read your reply so don't bother. Just stop wasting people's time. Trade J-Roll. Moron!

If the Phillies throw in Lito Sheppard with Jimmy Rollins, we actually might have a legit shot at landing Roy Williams or Chad Johnson. Seriously.....

LOL!

Great point philly5! LOL

No way they can't trade last years mvp.

WHO IS COMING UP WITH SH!!!!!T j-roll is the heart of phillies with speed and power---just because of run in with manager---thats baseball,he knows,he did not run hard---the manager made right decesion to bench his a!!!!s --- they have one of the best infield in baseball---SO HE DID NOT--HE HAS TO BE COCKY TO PLAY BASEBALL---just don't come complacent and lax---

we need pitching, but not that bad that we would trade the NL MVP