Originally posted on The Show Speak  |  Last updated 1/29/12

EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - NOVEMBER 8: Eli Manning #10 of the New York Giants drops back to pass against the San Diego Chargers at Giants Stadium on November 8, 2009 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. The Chargers defeated the Giants 21-20. (Photo by Nick Laham/Getty Images)
Ironic, as Super Bowl XLVI Indianapolis becomes the center of the universe this week, the only Manning not in the news is Cooper. 

Eli has led the New York Football Giants to their 2nd Super Bowl in five years, and this one happens to be in Peyton's house, Lucas Oil Stadium. 

Peyton Manning has been the best quarterback not named Brady over the last decade.  The Colts have 141-67 record since 1998 with Peyton barking out offensive plays, while leading them to three Super Bowl appearances.  Peyton has one Super Bowl ring to show for his efforts. 

He was the first pick by the colts in 1998 and has been the starter since draft day 1998. (Until this year's next injury sidelined him for the entire season) Peyton was 3-13 his first year and then proceeded lead the Horseshoe to ten wins or more in eleven out of twelve seasons.  Peyton has four NFL MVP's, 5X All Pro selection and a Super Bowl MVP for all his success.  Peyton's career playoff record is 9-10.

Elisha Manning (Eli) has been a little more of an enigma since being drafter number 1 by the San Diego Chargers in 2004.  Eli (or Dad Archie) expressed no interest in signing with the San Diego Super Chargers and a trade with the New York Giants was orchestrated.    Eli started the 2004 season on the bench behind future Hall of Fame QB Kurt Warner.  After nine games in 2004, Tom Coughlin replaced Warner as the starting quarterback and handed the reins over to Elisha who guided the Giants to a 1-6 record down the stretch. 

Eli led the Giants to a Super Bowl XLII victory over the New England Patriots in 2008.  He has a 7-3 career playoff record including three game winning drives.  Meanwhile, he has only led the Giants to ten plus win seasons four out of eight years.  Eli has matched Peyton's Super Bowl MVP, however, has not achieved All Pro status or been recognized as the league's MVP.

So, Eli or Peyton? 

Head to Head Regular Season Career Numbers:  (Pro Football Reference)
Career Reg. Season Peyton Manning Eli Manning Attempts 4682 2291 Completions 7210 3921 Yards 54828 27579 TD's 399 185 Int 198 129 Record 141-67 69-50

I will save the head to head analysis of the regular season.  Peyton wins in a landslide every year and every positive category.

(Archie, Peyton, Cooper, and Eli Manning - NY Daily News)
 Career Post Season Numbers for the Manning Bros. (minus Cooper)

Career Post Season Peyton Manning Eli Manning Completions 453 190 Attempts 718 316 Yards 5389 2220 TD's 29 15 Int 19 7 Record 9-10 7-3

These numbers tighten up significantly if you are comparing the two.  Each category is a push until you get to wins and losses.  In addition to Eli's superior win-loss percentage, he has three game winning playoff drives to Peyton's one. 
Interesting dichotomy between Peyton and Eli. 
Perhaps, Peyton received the quarterback talent gene, and Eli received the clutch gene? 
Anyhow, if Eli pulls another Super Bowl win over arch Manning nemesis Tom Brady, you can rest assure the debate on which Manning on your team would you rather have heats up the airwaves.
I'll take Peyton...in Arizona....after Jim Irsay releases him via twitter.
Until Next Time,

Craig Turley

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Did Suh make a statement with his footwear at practice?

Eagles C Jason Kelce: Offensive line is ‘a disgrace right now’

Report: Colts expect Andrew Luck to start Week 5

Dolphins DC Coyle more likely to be fired than Philbin

Jerry Jones: It’s hard to beat Brees with ‘limited’ Weeden

Report: Cowboys fear Lance Dunbar has torn ACL, MCL


Adam Schefter: Richard Sherman blocked me on Twitter

Martellus Bennett compared Jay Cutler to Jesus

Jimmy Johnson thinks 49ers need to move on from Colin Kaepernick

Pat Murphy won't be back as Padres manager next year

Brian Cushing's wife gets upset with Houston talk show host

Marshawn Lynch won't play against Lions on MNF

Looking back at Mark Buehrle's quietly efficient career

The 25 best NHL players under 25

Todd Gurley showed maturity beyond his years in Week 4

Five fantasy things we learned about every NFL Week 4 game

Six biggest flameout teams of 2015 college football season

LSU's Fournette highlights problem with rigid NFL rules

NFL stock report: Who is rising, falling after Week 4?

Top 10 takeaways from Sunday’s Week 4 NFL action

Eight notable NFL Week 4 winners and losers

Professor moves student’s exam to accommodate Cubs playoff game

WATCH: Adrian Peterson torches Broncos for marathon touchdown

Don Orsillo gives moving farewell to Red Sox fans on NESN

WATCH: Ichiro Suzuki takes the mound for the Marlins

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The 25 best NHL players under 25

Five fantasy things we learned about every NFL Week 4 game

Top 10 takeaways from Sunday’s Week 4 NFL action

Eight notable NFL Week 4 winners and losers

Jimmy Johnson: Move on from Kaepernick

WATCH: Ichiro Suzuki pitches for the Marlins

Philbin not worried about job status

London PR guy trolls Suh

10 takeaways from Week 5 of the college football season

Rick Pitino and the shadows that never leave

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker