Originally posted on This Given Sunday  |  Last updated 12/28/11

When you look at the NFC's Pro Bowl roster, it's hard to argue against any of the quarterbacks that made the cut. Aaron Rodgers should be a shoo in to win the 2011 MVP, and Drew Brees just eclipsed Dan Marion's single season passing record with another game to play. There's no doubt that they both deserve to be on the NFC's Pro Bowl squad. Eli Manning started his season with elite numbers, but he faded as the season went on. So, now that the Pro Bowl rosters are in, it's time to begin the debate. Eli Manning or Matthew Stafford?

At first glance, I was okay with putting Manning in the Pro Bowl over Stafford, but that was before I began looking at each quarterbacks' numbers. I hate the quarterback rating statistic, but it can be useful in getting a very basic comparison between two quarterbacks, and that's the way I used it when I looked at each quarterbacks' season.

Eli Manning has posted a game quarterback rating of 100.0 or higher just 5 times. In contrast, Matthew Stafford has accomplished that feat 9 times. On top of that, Manning has had a quarterback rating below 80 in 5 games, something Stafford has done just 4 times.

The next issue that we need to consider is that Matt Stafford has better receivers. That will certainly aid him in raising his passing statistics. By the same token, the Giants have a much more consistent defense that can keep its offense close in a game when Manning and the rest of the offense isn't performing at top level. All considered, it's impossible to compare apples and oranges, but I'd call those two factors a wash. Eli Manning does throw to a very good group of receivers, and the Lions have a very formidable defense, at times.

Another wash between the two quarterbacks comes with their completion percentages. While Stafford's completion percentage is slightly higher (63.7% to 60.3%), it's hardly enough to be considered hugely significant.

The final pair of statistics are almost always put side by side. I'm talking about the most basic way of comparing a quarterback's efficiency; touchdowns and interceptions. Eli Manning has thrown 26 touchdowns and 16 interceptions. While that's an impressive ration of touchdowns to interceptions, it's not as impressive as Matthew Stafford's ratio of 36 touchdowns to 14 interceptions.

Now we can get back to our core debate. Was Matthew Stafford snubbed? Yes. Even if we don't consider mitigating factors in this discussion, Stafford has had a more impressive year. When you consider that fact that the Lions haven't been to the playoffs since the 20th century, there's really no argument. Matthew Stafford was snubbed hands down.

While Matthew Stafford wasn't selected to go to the Pro Bowl, it's likely that he'll find himself there anyway. The chances are that one of the three quarterbacks in front of him will be headed to Indianapolis for the Super Bowl, ruling them out for the NFL's all-star game. He deserves to go, and the only way he shouldn't be there should come in the form of a Super Bowl trip for the Lions. Matthew Stafford was snubbed, plain and simple.

Follow @smaclemons on Twitter [follow]

This article first appeared on This Given Sunday and was syndicated with permission.

GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Jamaal Charles could be on the roster bubble

Jimmy Butler on state of Bulls: ‘I just want to win at all costs’

Report: Giants will be ‘aggressive’ in trying to sign Jason Pierre-Paul

Report: Porzingis avoided ligament damage in ankle

Brooks Koepka meltdown includes whiff, stomping head off driver

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Report: 49ers could talk trade for QB at the NFL Scouting Combine

Hawks suspend Dennis Schroder for one game

Mike Pereira: Chips in footballs wouldn’t improve spotting

Tony Romo takes great shot at Jimmy Kimmel ahead of Oscars

Report: Pelicans sign veteran G Jarrett Jack

Carmelo Anthony does not understand direction of Knicks

Eat, Drink, Watch: Your award-worthy weekend planning guide

Grading the NBA trade deadline on the Vince Carter scale

Box Score 2/24: A night of NBA disrespect

As NHL trade deadline nears, seven teams who could be dealing

The 'Pete Rose instead of Kareem? Surely, you can't be serious' quiz

Streaming sports docuseries you don't want to miss

Teams that can prevent a Cavs-Warriors NBA Finals three-peat

The NFL off-season is a passer’s fancy

The Aesthetic: Pushing the boundaries of the three-pointer

NBA coaches who should be fired soon

The top 10 MLB third basemen heading into spring training

Nintendo is finally, thankfully embracing sports and eSports

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Eat, Drink, Watch: Your award-worthy weekend planning guide

Grading the NBA trade deadline on the Vince Carter scale

Streaming sports docuseries you don't want to miss

As NHL trade deadline nears, seven teams who could be dealing

The 'Pete Rose instead of Kareem? Surely, you can't be serious' quiz

Teams that can prevent a Cavs-Warriors NBA Finals three-peat

The NFL off-season is a passer’s fancy

QUIZ: Name every MLB pitcher who has recorded 10 or more shutouts in a single season

The top 10 MLB third basemen heading into spring training

The Aesthetic: Pushing the boundaries of the three-pointer

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker