Found November 21, 2011 on Fox Sports:
The emails and tweets from Penn State supporters are trickling in, the ones asking why the media are not clamoring for Syracuse basketball coach Jim Boeheim to resign and his longtime assistant Bernie Fine to be jailed. This one, from reader Jason Devitt, arrived Monday morning: "I find it interesting that Joe Paterno absolutely had to be immediately fired, could not coach a single game more, 60 years of reputation means nothing. Yet with Bernie Fine everyone is taking the let's-wait-until-all-the-facts-are-out-to-pass-judgment approach. Maybe people just aren't as disgusted by sexual abuse anymore." Or, maybe some of us are disgusted by the irresponsible "reporting" used by Mark Schwarz, Arty Berko and ESPN to unfairly smear Bernie Fine and boost ESPN ratings. Schwarz, Berko and ESPN remind me of Paterno, Mike McQueary and Penn State in one respect. When confronted with a difficult choice, they all did the bare, legal minimum to protect their self-interest. They failed their moral obligation. This column is not meant to exonerate Bernie Fine, whom Syracuse put on administrative leave pending an ESPN-driven police investigation into whether he sexually molested step brothers and former SU ball boys Bobby Davis and Mike Lang in the 1970s, '80s and '90s. I do not know Bernie Fine. I do not have any insight into what did or did not transpire between Fine and his two accusers. What I do know, based on Schwarz's juvenile "reporting," is the Worldwide Leader didn't have nearly enough evidence to air such a reputation-damaging story. Schwarz acquired just enough information -- two vague, mumbling on-camera interviews from Fine's accusers -- to protect ESPN from a lawsuit. Schwarz did the legal minimum. Was his story sound journalism? Was his story remotely fair? No, and hell no. Let me repeat: I'm not exonerating Bernie Fine. I don't know him. I don't know what he's capable of doing and/or hiding. What I know is you don't destroy a person's reputation with two highly flimsy accusations. The accusations against Fine are nothing like the accusations against Jerry Sandusky. There were multiple eyewitnesses -- including a Penn State assistant coach -- to Sandusky's alleged criminal behavior. There was a three-year investigation into Sandusky, a grand jury indictment, an arrest and a public statement by the Pennsylvania state police criticizing Paterno and McQueary for failing to meet their moral obligation. Are police, prosecutors, grand juries and eyewitnesses infallible? No. They get things wrong all the time. And maybe they screwed up the Sandusky investigation. And maybe Sandusky's repulsive interview with Bob Costas was just another big misunderstanding. But, for now, journalists and broadcasters were/are on solid ground condemning Sandusky and his Paterno State enablers. There is no solid ground when it comes to the Bernie Fine investigation. The police, ESPN, The (Syracuse) Post-Standard and Syracuse University all looked into Bobby Davis' accusations years ago. His allegations couldn't be corroborated or proved. His relationship with Fine appeared to be quite complicated. In 2001 -- a year before Davis, now 39, told Syracuse police Fine had molested him from age 12 to 27 -- Davis cut off all contact with Fine because Davis said Fine choked him over a $5,000 debt, according to The Post-Standard. Lang, now 45, was interviewed by The Post-Standard in 2003, and, according to the newspaper, Lang did not corroborate Davis' story then. Lang was a Syracuse ball boy years before Davis. So we're now to believe Lang was molested by Fine but told his younger stepbrother to be a Syracuse ball boy and it was cool to hang out with Bernie Fine. Really? In the brief snippet of interviews ESPN has aired of Davis and Lang, why didn't Schwarz ask any probative questions? Davis and Lang are grown men who mustered the courage to go on national television and talk about being fondled by another man two decades ago but they can't handle a few clarifying questions? Really? Oprah Winfrey would've asked more difficult questions than Schwarz did. It's morally criminal what Schwarz and ESPN did to Bernie Fine. Even if other, more credible accusers against Fine surface, it does not justify what Schwarz did to Fine. This can't be the standard. The mainstream media can't simply throw out crippling, salacious rumors and then let the proof of those rumors filter in. If that's the standard, a lot of people -- including members of the media -- are going to get hurt. And that explains how this happened. Deadspin.com has gained a huge following sifting through the personal-life rumor mill of ESPN personalities/executives and athletes. In its infancy, Deadspin published a story about a married ESPN anchor's midnight text to a female peer. Last year, Deadspin hit it big with the Brett Favre-Jenn Sterger controversy. Recently the website has published multiple stories about inappropriate sexual relationships on the Bristol campus. If you can't beat 'em, join 'em. After being embarrassingly slow to react to the legitimate Penn State story, ESPN decided to "own" the Syracuse story by adopting what it believes is Deadspin's standard for destroying a person's reputation. The truth is, Deadspin actually has a higher standard than the Worldwide Leader. "Honestly, no," responded Deadspin editor A.J. Daulerio when I asked via email if he would've run the Fine story. "And for no other reason than the fact that it seemed very presumptive and piggybacked off the Sandusky case, which irretrievably alters the public perception of the story. Davis's story could wait another month or two." Like a lot of other journalists, I'm more than willing to sit back and let ESPN "own" the Bernie Fine story for now. If this latest round of investigations once again proves that Jim Boeheim is right about the character and integrity of his longtime friend and assistant, I'll "own" the Mark Schwarz story.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Syracuse's Boeheim repeats support for Fine at NIT

In the New York City spotlight, Jim Boeheim is not changing his stance on longtime assistant coach Bernie Fine. No. 5 Syracuse will play Virginia Tech on Wednesday in the NIT Season Tip-Off at Madison Square Garden without Fine, on administrative leave after child molestation allegations resurfaced. Fine has called the accusations ''patently false.'' Surrounded...

Bad Idea Holiday Card Photos: Posing Kids In Front Of Joe Paterno’s Statue

Hoo boy. Here’s the Reuters’ caption for the above photo (via Off the Bench): Courtney Kriley of State College, Pennsylvania, takes photos of her children Brian (4) and Alexandra (7) at the Joe Paterno statue in State College, Pennsylvania November 19, 2011. The photos will be for their Christmas card. Either Courtney Kriley isn’t keeping [...]

Syracuse Trounces Colgate in Wake of Scandal; Boeheim Defends Fine

In Syracuse, the focus on this college basketball Saturday wasn’t hoops but scandal. Playing for the first time since Jim Boeheim‘s top assistant Bernie Fine was accused of child sex abuse, #5 Syracuse destroyed Colgate 92-47. Normally, a Big East traditional power trouncing a low-major cupcake in the early season is not big news, but today it is. From the AP: Syracuse placed...

Penn State gets first win without Paterno

No. 21 Penn State won for the first time since coach Joe Paterno was fired, with Stephfon Green running for two touchdowns and the Nittany Lions' solid defense holding Ohio State scoreless in the second half of a 20-14 victory Saturday. Penn State (9-2, 6-1) earned a share of the Big Ten's Leaders Division title and set up a division title game next week at Wisconsin. The...

Report: Football player treatment questioned

Former Penn State student disciplinarian Vicky Triponey tells The Wall Street Journal that football players were treated ''more favorably than other students accused of violating the community standards as defined by the student code of conduct.'' Triponey, who resigned her post as the university's standards and conduct officer in 2007, spoke to the newspaper...

Former PSU Administrator: Joe Paterno Demanded His Own Code Of Justice—And Code Of Silence—For Infractions By Players

In September of 2007, Vicky Triponey resigned as Penn State's vice president for student affairs, a job that included overseeing the school's Office of Judicial Affairs. In an interview two weeks later, she attributed her departure to what the Centre County Daily Times described as "philosophical differences with other leadership in...

Penn State beats Ohio State for 1st post-Paterno victory

Penn State won for the first time since coach Joe Paterno was fired, beating Ohio State 20-14 in Columbus, Ohio, on Saturday.

Headlinin’: Former discipline head leads the skeletons out of Paterno’s closet

Making the morning rounds. • It's only going to get uglier. In the first of what figures to be a parade of old grudges marching out of the ruins at Penn State, the Wall Street Journal reported Monday night that ousted coach Joe Paterno "clashed repeatedly" with the university's former discipline officer over her efforts to impose punishment for football players...

No. 21 Penn St. 20, Ohio St. 14

No. 21 Penn State won for the first time since coach Joe Paterno was fired, with Stephfon Green running for two touchdowns and the Nittany Lions' solid defense holding Ohio State scoreless in the second half of a 20-14 victory Saturday. Penn State (9-2, 6-1) earned a share of the Big Ten's Leaders Division title and set up a division title game next week at Wisconsin. The...

Report: 'Victim One' of Sexual Abuse Allegations Against Jerry Sandusky Leaves School Due to Bullying Over Scandal

The first known victim of the alleged sexual abuse by former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky had to leave his school because of bullying, according to a report. Students at Central Mountain High School in Clinton County, Pa., were blaming the 17-year-old for head coach Joe Paterno's firing, Mike Gillum, counselor of the boy known as "Victim One,"...

Report: JoePa resisted player discipline (AP)

A former Penn State official charged with enforcing discipline at the school said Tuesday that Joe Paterno's players got in trouble more often than other students, and got special treatment compared to non-athletes. Vicky Triponey, who resigned her post as the university's standards and conduct officer in 2007, confirmed that she sent a 2005 email to then-president Graham Spanier and...

Ex-PSU officer questioned player treatment

A former Penn State official charged with enforcing discipline at the school said Tuesday that Joe Paterno's players got in trouble more often than other students, and got special treatment compared to non-athletes.
All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.