Found April 30, 2012 on NASCAR Racing Scene:
It is no secret, NASCAR has had some credibility issues over the years.  Inconsistent calls from officials are almost expected.  On Saturday, NASCAR's credibility came into question once again. 

First, officials apparently gave Carl Edwards' spotter Jason Hedlesky inaccurate information when they supposedly told him that the No. 99 was the leader.  The No. 99 was also shown as the lead on the leaderboard. Therefore, Edwards took off like a rocket ship on the 317 restart while Stewart, the real leader, appeared to have spun his tires.  NASCAR black flagged Edwards, leaving the driver and his team utterly perplexed.  NASCAR stated that Stewart was indeed the leader and Edwards was in violation of jumping the restart.

While I see Edwards' frustration, it did appear that Edwards restarted earlier than he should have, even if he was the leader.  Nevertheless, NASCAR should at least acknowledge that they gave Edwards' spotter incorrect information.  To my knowledge they have not owned up to it.

With 14 laps to go, NASCAR threw a fifth caution flag, this time for debris.  Stewart was the leader and steadily sailing away from second place driver Kyle Busch.   While Stewart could have still won the race had his pit crew not flubbed the final pit stop, the victory was not in the bank as it was prior to the caution.  Busch's crew performed a swift pit stop, putting the No. 18 Toyota in the lead.  He easily won the race. 

Meanwhile, Stewart lost second place to Dale Earnhardt Jr.  Following the race, Stewart was seething, claiming the a water bottle sitting outside the racing groove was the reason for the caution. 

"(We) lost it on a plastic bottle on the backstretch," he said after the race.

While NASCAR officials stated that a piece of sheet metal was the debris, it was not confirmed by the ones who are the most important, and that is the fans. 

I have always said that if NASCAR feels the need to throw a debris caution, they need to alert the camera guys and put it on TV for all to see.  There are many times when the camera does focus on the debris, but all too often, we are left wondering, 'what's the real reason for the caution'?  I mean, how many fans really trust NASCAR's judgement? 

I understand that proof of debris will not fix all of NASCAR's credibility issues, but at least it will erase the notion that they manufacture cautions in order to bunch up the field.  As far as becoming credible with the fans, NASCAR has a steep hill to climb.

Edwards, Stewart question NASCAR calls

I think the penalty we saw go against Carl Edwards on Saturday night in Richmond was right there on the edge. The penalty came late in the race, when NASCAR flagged Edwards for jumping the restart. That cost him a shot at the win in a race where he had led more than 200 laps. Now we felt pretty confident of what we were saying Saturday evening on air when this happened, because...

NASCAR at Richmond: Tempers Run High As Stewart and Edwards Fall Short

Tony Stewart was one unhappy man following Saturday night's Sprint Cup race at Richmond International Raceway. Although Stewart has mellowed considerably since becoming an owner-driver in 2009, the sport's reigning champion still has a temper to match his nickname of "Smoke." And you could almost see the smoke coming from his ears after a late debris caution...

Edwards and Stewart leave Richmond unhappy

(Eds: Updates with quotes, details With AP Photos.) By JENNA FRYER AP Auto Racing Writer Not even a meeting with NASCAR officials helped Carl Edwards understand why he was given a penalty at Richmond International Raceway. ''We had to just agree to disagree and that's the way it is,'' Edwards said. In contrast, Tony Stewart knew exactly why he lost Saturday...

Costly mistakes will haunt top drivers

For many of NASCAR's top competitors, Richmond will be remembered for the race that got away. While race winner Kyle Busch exclaimed, "What up boys, we back," as he came to the checkered flag at Richmond International Raceway on Saturday night, Jimmie Johsnon, Dale Earnhardt Jr., Tony Stewart and Carl Edwards were trying to ascertain what went wrong. Johnson's...

Kyle Busch Capitalizes on Late-Race Confusion to Pick Up Victory at Richmond

RICHMOND, Va. -- Carl Edwards thought the race was his to win. So did Tony Stewart. And Kyle Busch? Well, he didn't think he had a chance as the laps wound down at Richmond International Raceway. But a penalty on Edwards took him out of contention Saturday night, and a late caution flag for debris gobbled up Stewart's lead and gave Busch one last chance at another Richmond...

Did Miscommunication Between NASCAR & Driver Cost Carl Edwards A Win?

photo credit:  getty images Carl Edwards was black flagged for jumping the start on a late race restart Saturday night in the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series race at Richmond International Raceway. Following the race, Edwards said he was told by NASCAR that he was the leader, so he led the field the green and pulled away from the inside car of Tony Stewart. NASCAR however told Edwards...

Mark Martin Wins Pole at Richmond for Fifth Time in His Career

RICHMOND, Va. -- Mark Martin watched and waited as 44 other drivers made two qualifying laps around Richmond International Raceway on Friday night. He then went out and beat them all. Martin turned the second-fastest lap on his first circuit around the 0.75-mile, D-shaped oval, then nudged Carl Edwards to the outside of the front row with a lap at 128.327 mph to win the pole for...
All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.