Found April 10, 2013 on
Fox Sports Southwest:
The idea of paying college athletes for their services has grown a great deal within the last couple of years. To make it simple, the argument is that the term "student-athlete" was created by the NCAA a long time ago as a way of ducking labor laws, and it should no longer be able to get away with that because in reality all it's doing is keeping the most valuable laborers in a multi-billion-dollar industry from getting fair compensation.
Ok, well, Oklahoma football coach Bob Stoops was asked about the whole issue, and he took the position that basically the players are getting fair compensation. Stoops, as told to AOL:
"I tell my guys all the time," Stoops says, "you're not the first one to spend a hungry Sunday without any money."
"You know what school would cost here for non-state guy? Over 200,000 for room, board and everything else," Stoops said. "That's a lot of money. Ask the kids who have to pay it back over 10-15 years with student loans. You get room and board, and we'll give you the best nutritionist, the best strength coach to develop you, the best tutors to help you academically, and coaches to teach you and help you develop. How much do you think it would cost to hire a personal trainer and tutor for 4-5 years?"
Interesting points, but even if you accept the argument that room and board is a form of compensation, you have to acknowledge that what the schools are doing , in effect, is converting the actual U.S. currency they receive from ticket sales and television rights deals into "NCAA Bucks," spendable only at select NCAA Institutions. You see? A player isn't given U.S. dollars so he can go shop around for the best value on a trainer or tutor or apartment, he's being given the only trainer, tutor or apartment available to him and then being told how much it's worth after the fact. But according to whom?
Would you consider that acceptable compensation from your employer? The tools and training necessary to do your job, plus living quarters of your employer's choosing?
This issue is far from simple, and nobody yet has come up with a way of compensating college athletes in a way that is fair, non-hypocritical and not damaging to the sport or ripe for corruption. Many of the benefits of being a college athlete are qualitative rather than quantitative, and that will never change. A college athlete, generally speaking, is a very desirable thing to be. If the deal was bad, people wouldn't be dying to take it.
And if all Stoops is trying to say is that it's not like these guys are given nothing for their services, it's a reasonable argument. But he seems to be implying that the school actually provides these athletes with trainers and tutors because it feels it needs to compensate them for their work. But, no, it is the work. It's just part of the big machine. Oklahoma needs its players in tip-top shape and academically eligible in order to beat Texas or whoever and get on the big TV games.
It's nice that the player benefits from it personally, but we don't count "getting to work with a producer and good microphones" part of the compensation package of a pop star. "Getting to see the countryside" isn't considered part of a trucker's salary. "Gym access" doesn't have to be negotiated into NBA contracts.
All that stuff Stoops mentioned is just the stuff that is necessary to keep the machine running. The question isn't whether or not the machine is expensive to run, it's whether you have to pay the help.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
DEAL WITH IT
Oklahoma Sooners head football coach Bob Stoops says he isn't about to begin to feel too sorry for college football players because they are not paid.
Bob Stoops' comments to Matt Hayes of SportingNews.com in a column earlier this week touched off a big of firestorm about compensation for college athletes. One thing I happened to notice from the jump: For all the bluster from Stoops about athletes going hungry and and the value of a college scholarship, Stoops never said he's against full-cost-of-attendance scholarships...
So, apparently, Bob Stoops has an opinion about the pay-for-play proposals for college athletes. OK, a strong opinion.
In an interview with Matt Hayes of SportingNews.com, Stoops dismissed the suggestion of stipends for athletes. He did it in his typically blunt fashion, which naturally caught the attention of the national media.
A guy who makes $5 million a year comes out...
The debate about whether or not college athletes should get paid beyond what the description of their scholarship entails has been a hot one recently.Count Oklahoma's Bob Stoops as one person who doesn't believe college athletes should share the whopping revenue generated by the NCAA system.From the Sporting News:"I don't get why people say these guys don't get...
Bob Stoops or “Big game Bob” if you’re from the state of Texas, was asked his opinion on whether or not college athletes should be paid.It must be stated that Stoops takes home an annual salary of nearly $5 million for coaching players that take home an annual salary of $0. But Stoops is perfectly fine with this fact. And even contends that college athletes shouldn’t be paid...
Tweet The biggest debate in college football over the last few years has been whether or not the student athletes deserve more monetary compensation from all the revenue they generate for the universities and NCAA as a whole. Well apparently Oklahoma Sooners head coach Bob Stoops is on the side of not paying players, according [...]
No matter what Bob Stoops says, the status quo is not a solution for college athletics. Oklahoma's head football coach, a man I like and respect, recycled a well-worn defense of the shamateurism status quo in an interview with Sporting News columnist Mike Hayes.
"You know what school would cost here for non-state guy?" Stoops rhetorically asked Hayes. "Over $200...
Oklahoma football coach Bob Stoops is one of the highest-paid coaches in sports — not just collegiate athletics. His roughly $5 million-per-season salary ranks him among some of the most legendary coaches in NCAA, NFL, MLB and NBA history. He has brought a lot of money to the university, but so have the players.
The topic of collegiate athletes being compensated for their work...
Freshman defensive end D.J. Ward practiced for the first time at Oklahoma on Tuesday after being declared eligible by the NCAA.
Coach Bob Stoops said Ward was able to start working on his fundamentals and learning the Sooners' defense, but his participation was limited under NCAA rules. Ward was required to practice without shoulder pads and in a helmet only, limiting what he...
Oklahoma coach Bob Stoops gave a candid interview this week with Matt Hayes of SportingNews.com that touched off a national debate of compensation for college football players. NCAA expert John Infante of athleticscholarships.net's Bylaw Blog joins CBR's Allen Kenney for a podcast to discuss the compensation issue from all sides.
John and Allen touch on:
NORMAN, Okla. (AP) -- Freshman defensive end D.J. Ward, one of the top prospects in Oklahoma's recruiting class and ranked the top in-state player by recruiting services, practiced with the Sooners for the first time Tuesday after being declared eligible by the NCAA.
Coach Bob Stoops said NCAA rules require Ward to go through his first two practices in a helmet only, without...
Way back in 2007, Oklahoma hosted Missouri in a battle for Big 12 supremacy so big that ESPN GameDay made its way to Norman for the game. Actually, that has been pretty commonplace at OU since Chris, Lee and Kirk started blazing a trail around the United States chasing the best matchups college football has to offer. I remember essentially nothing from the broadcast, expect for one...
Dancing in the Ruins - the new Big 12 emerging from the ruins of the old.
Allen Kenney points out how Oklahoma head football coach Bob Stoops' habit of blocking access to his team from both the media and the Sooner fanbase hurts the team when it comes to areas like recruiting and creating a buzz around the program. (Blatant Homerism)
CBR's tour around spring camps looking at some of the biggest position battles continues with a trip to Oklahoma, where the Sooners are looking for the next passer to keep their offensive machine rolling.
Since Bob Stoops arrived at Oklahoma, prolific passers under center have become a given. None of them took more snaps for the Sooners than Landry Jones, who...