Found May 23, 2013 on
Hall of Very Good:
When Topps recently issued a card of Dodgers rookie Hyun-Jin Ryu and couldn’t tell the difference between Japan and Korea, I thought it would be interested to look at the issue of race and baseball cards.
It turns out this is a legitimate area of scholarly research.
Because baseball cards have one player with an easily identifiable race, and also have well-publicized prices that are driven by the consumer market, they have been a fruitful hunting ground for economists looking at the impact of race on consumer behavior.
Here are the ten most prominent articles on the topic – one early newspaper article, eight professional journal articles, and finally, a recent piece by a sabermetric blogger.
Racism Abounds In World Of Old-Time Baseball Cards  by Marty York
An early article that makes some great points still relevant today: Why are Mickey Mantle cards worth so much more than Mays or Aaron? Why are Koufax rookies twice the value of Bob Gibsons? Why is Brooks Robinson’s card worth so much more than Frank’s? Hank Aaron is among those quoted in the article.
Customer Racial Discrimination for Baseball Memorabilia  by Paul Gabriel, Curtis Johnson and Timothy Stanton
This study found that rookie card prices were not affected by ethnicity early in a players career, but discrepancies due to race increased later in a players career and after retirement. Full text preview only.
Location, Location, Location: The Transmission of Racist Ideology in Baseball Cards  by Robert Regoli, John Hewitt, Robert Munoz and Adam Regoli
Traditionally Topps assigned the cards with 00 numbers (100, 200, 300 etc) to the biggest stars in baseball. These authors find that black players were underrepresented from 1956-1966, and then overrepresented from 1967-1980. The authors say that this may have been due to the effect of the Civil Rights Movement. Free full text is not available.
Incidentally, noted baseball card blogger Night Owl has done his own research and found that Topps didn’t consistently devote themselves to putting a star at these numbers until 1962. His link contains the entire list of “hero numbers” for those who are interested:
A Reinvestigation of Racial Discrimination and Baseball Cards  by Edward Scahill
An economist finds that nonwhite star player cards are undervalued compared to those of white stars. He finds that this is consumer-driven, rather than dealer driven.
Race, Performance and Baseball Card Values  by John Hewitt, Robert Munoz, William Oliver and Robert Regoli
Four economists did an analysis on statistical difference in card values for black and white Hall of Famers (later corrected and updated, see below). No free full text version available online.
Where O Where Did My Baseball Cards Go?: Race, Performance and Placement in the Topps Era, 1956-1980  by John Hewitt, Eric Primm and Robert Regoli
Topps would give out the hundred-number cards to star players. Was this based on performance or race? According to this Social Science Journal article, it was by performance. Free full text version is not available.
Assessing Consumer Preference for Hall of Fame Baseball Cards  by Michael McAvoy
Statistical analysis using hedonic pricing model. Finds that collectors discriminate only against pitchers of color, not hitters. [From Wikipedia – hedonic regression “decomposes the item being researched into its constituent characteristics, and obtains estimates of the contributory value of each characteristic.”]
Race Effects on Ebay  by Ian Ayres, Mahzarin Banaji and Christine Jolls
Two Yale economists and a Harvard psychologist conduct an experiment comparing the winning bids on baseball cards held by a black hand in their eBay photo versus those held by a white hand. Cards held by black hands sold for 20% less. The negative effect increased when a black player appeared on a card held by a black hand, and when the buyer came from a “whiter” zip code.
Race, Ethnicity, and Baseball Card Prices: A Replication, Correction, and Extension of Hewitt, Muñoz, Oliver and Regoli 
Two economists correct several statistical errors in the early work by Hewit Munoz, Oliver and Regoli [HMOR]. They find no effect of race on card prices after their corrections of HMOR’s data errors. One of the original authors, Robert Munoz, graciously accepted the corrections and new results.
Racial Bias and Baseball Card Values  by Phil Birnbaum
A sabermetric blogger find some baseball-related issues with the HMOR article. The only piece I’ve found written from a baseball fan, rather than an economist, point of view. Birnbaum points out the weaknesses in using only one statistical rating to measure player value, and using PSA to determine card scarcity.
You can read more from Bo Rosny over at his site Baseball Cards Come to Life.
BEST OF MAXIM
Just two days ago, I wrote on Yahoo! Sports that Don Mattingly shouldn't yet be fired. Today, I may have changed my tune.
Just in front of Wednesday's matinee series finale with the Brewers, Bill Plunkett of the Orange County Register brought us these comments from the soon-to-be-former Dodger manager.
"Must-read strong comments from #Dodgers mgr Don Mattingly...
Yesterday, Don Mattingly had what I call a “Wu-Tang moment”, inspired by the “When Keeping It Real Goes Wrong” skit on Chappelle’s Show.
Humorous? Yes, but what it mean to me is that Mattingly basically dropped all the fronts and simply went in on the Dodgers players and front office in surprisingly pointed comments.
“We’re in last place in the National League West...
The Dodgers have a propensity for drafting players who are athletic and two-way guys. Darren Dreifort was one of the more notable ones, when the team made him the No. 2 draft pick in the 1993 MLB Draft. While most viewed him as a pitcher, the guy could hit.
James Loney was viewed by many as a pitching prospect in 2002. The Dodgers made him a first baseman. Ethan Martin was...
It may have been an accident, but Matt Kemp didn't do a whole lot to endear himself to home plate umpire Wally Bell on May 21.
Video: Matt Kemp rocks home plate umpire Wally Bell’s face mask
The post Matt Kemp rocks umpire Wally Bell’s face mask with a foul appeared first on Players View.
All winter, there were rumors that the Dodgers were open to trading Andre Ethier. All winter, the Dodgers declared that there was nothing to those rumors, and that they weren’t having second thoughts about the five year, $85 million contract they gave him last June. When spring training rolled around and Cuban import Yasiel Puig became The Hot New Thing, those rumors picked up...
Brandon League has been trying to do just about anything to give away his closer’s role. Despite League’s high salary and multi-year contract, the embattled closer has a 5.51 ERA and has lead the Dodgers to one of the worst bullpens in baseball, one of many problems currently impacting the expensive NL West team.
Kenley Jansen would be the natural pick to replace League should...
The Dodgers signed former Giants and Royals lefty Jonathan Sanchez to a minor-league deal, sending him to the Albuquerque Isotopes.
2:17pm: The Dodgers will sign Jonathan Sanchez to a minor league deal, according to Pedro Gomez of ESPN (on Twitter). The contract is pending a physical, and Sanchez is likely to report to Triple-A Albquerque. Sanchez is represented by the McNamara Baseball...
Tweet Los Angeles Dodgers star Matt Kemp pledged to donate $1000 to the victims of the Oklahoma tornadoes for every home run he hit until the All-Star break following Monday night’s Dodger game. An Oklahoma City native, Kemp has now scratched that idea and will donate a $250,000 straight up to the victims of the [...]
Andre Ethier was ejected in the eighth inning of the Los Angeles Dodgers’ 3-1 win over the Milwaukee Brewers on Monday night for apparently arguing balls and strikes. He also may have been upset over Brewers pitcher Michael Gonzalez throwing a pitch over his head on an 0-2 count and not being warned, but none of that really matters.
The real takeaway here is the death stare Ethier...
If you hear a rapping noise odds are it’s the sound of the nails on the coffin encasing Don Mattingly’s job as Dodgers manager closing.
Mattingly broke a cardinal rule and shredded his own team in the midst of their struggle, instead of taking the blame.
During Wednesday’s pregame Mattingly ranted like a man who’d given up on his 19-26 team:
“We gotta find a team with...
Los Angeles manager Don Mattingly has been sharply critical of his slumping team.
For at least one day, everything was all right with the embattled Dodgers.
Carl Crawford and Scott Van Slyke drove in two runs each and Ramon Hernandez hit his first home run in the Dodgers' 9-2 win over the Milwaukee Brewers on Wednesday.
Even after the win, the Dodgers are last in the NL West...
On this episode of "Dugout Blues," Jared Massey (Dodger Diamond) talk all about the Don Mattingly saga and whether he's as much to blame for the Dodgers' problems as the media is making it out to be.
We talk a little MLB Draft and reveal our preliminary big boards. Safe to say, its chock full of prep pitchers.
To close, well, we answer a myriad of listener...
For better or for worse, the Dodgers offense has basically followed Matt Kemp’s lead since 2010. Following a breakout 2009 and the departure of Manny Ramirez, Kemp slumped miserably in 2010 and the team’s offense followed suit. He then single-handedly buoyed a terrible lineup in 2011, and he was well on his way towards doing the same in 2012 before injuries struck.
When Don Mattingly said Wednesday that the Dodgers could not expect to win simply by putting together a collection of All-Stars, many interpreted the manager's remarks as criticism of the team's front office and ownership.
Dodgers president Stan Kasten did not see it that way.
"I know what Don is trying to do, what his intention is," Kasten told FOXSports.com...