Ranking fantasy football kickers isn’t easy. The best real-life kicker doesn’t necessarily produce the most fantasy points every week, and matchups can completely change the equation.
The Indianapolis Colts have been trying to find their starting kicker all training camp. After a fierce battle, head coach Shane Steichen has made his decision.
Of all the Indianapolis Colts position battles we have watched unfold throughout training camp, the most interesting competition has been at a position you might not expect: Kicker.
How many of the active NFL players to rush for at least 150 yards in a game can you name in five minutes?
After winning the competition to become the Colts’ kicker last summer, Spencer Shrader opened the 2025 season on a heater. Shrader nailed 13 of 14 field goals, including all five in a Week 2 defeat of the Broncos, and was perfect on 14 extra points in the Colts’ first five games.
A few trades have rearranged the NFL's backup quarterback ranks, but the dust has mostly settled. From a mix of recent first-round disappointments, aging vets, and young project types, here is how the league's QB2 ranks look for the 2026 season.
WESTFIELD, IN -- The Indianapolis Colts entered training camp with the most talented kicking competition amongst all NFL teams. Veterans Blake Grupe and Spencer Shrader have both proven to be viable starting options in the NFL, but one has begun to separate themself as the favorite to earn the opening.
The Indianapolis Colts entered training camp with several position battles to settle, but one of the most competitive could come at kicker. Second-year K Spencer Shrader and veteran K Blake Grupe both proved last season that they are capable of handling the job.
The Indianapolis Colts enter 2026 with an apparent kicking competition between two proven players, both of whom were near-perfect for the team last season: Spencer Shrader and Blake Grupe.
The Indianapolis Colts are heading into a clash with the NFC West mainstay, the Arizona Cardinals, tomorrow at Lucas Oil Stadium. This contest is after the Colts systematically destroyed the Las Vegas Raiders last Sunday, 40-6.
The Indianapolis Colts' celebration of their Week 5 win over the Las Vegas Raiders came to a halt due to a devastating injury. During the Colts' win, they saw kicker Spencer Shrader take a hit from a Raiders defender after an extra point.
Colts LS Luke Rhodes said it was hard to see K Spencer Shrader suffer a knee injury that will sideline him for the rest of the season. “I just prayed for him at halftime,” Rhodes said, via the team’s website.
NFL stars can't play forever, and retirement is coming sooner than later for some of the league's top players. These 25 players could call it quits following the 2026 season.
The Colts are adding a familiar leg, signing veteran kicker Michael Badgley to the 53-man roster after Spencer Shrader sustained a season-ending knee injury in Week 5.
The Indianapolis Colts announced they have placed K Spencer Shrader and CB Mike Hilton (practice squad) on injured reserve. This was the expected move for Shrader who suffered a season-ending knee injury Sunday.
The Indianapolis Colts have signed a new kicker. The Colts were searching for a new kicker after Spencer Shrader suffered a season-ending knee injury during his team’s 40-6 win over the Las Vegas Raiders in Week 5.
Spencer Shrader's season-ending injury will force the Colts to make another change at kicker.
The Indianapolis Colts have been humming so far through five weeks of the NFL season, sitting at a great 4-1 record. The offense and defense have both played well, complementing each other perfectly.
Indianapolis Colts kicker Spencer Shrader was lost for the season following a right knee injury during Sunday's 40-6 victory over the Las Vegas Raiders, multiple outlets reported.
The knee injury Colts K Spencer Shrader suffered on Sunday will knock him out for the rest of the 2025 season, per ESPN. Pat McAfee said he talked to Shrader
Each week of the NFL season, Yardbarker will be monitoring players who have suffered notable injuries. From an Arizona Cardinals quarterback to a New York Giants wide receiver, here are five players we're tracking after Week 5:
The newly named AFC Special Teams Player of the Month for September has been ruled out for the remainder of the Colts' Week 5 matchup against the Raiders.
The Indianapolis Colts have had a great start to their 2025 season, finishing 3-1 in September. While Daniel Jones has been a big surprise for the franchise, others have stood out as staples of the squad.
Spencer Shrader kicked a 45-yard field goal with no time left, his fifth of the game, and the host Indianapolis Colts rallied to beat the Denver Broncos 29-28 on Sunday.
After spending 2024 as a spot starter for three different teams, Indianapolis Colts kicker Spencer Shrader has firmly positioned himself to take over a full-time starting job this season.
The Indianapolis Colts announced Thursday that they’ve signed K Spencer Shrader to an undisclosed contract. Shrader, 25, signed with Indianapolis as an UDFA out of Notre Dame following the 2024 NFL Draft.
The Kansas City Chiefs placed rookie kicker Spencer Shrader on injured reserve due to a right hamstring injury and signed kicker Matthew Wright to the active roster from the practice squad on Wednesday.
Kansas City will be employing their third kicker of the year on Friday.
The good news is that Spencer Shrader had his moment. Just a couple of weeks after signing with the Kansas City Chiefs, Shrader, formerly of the New York
At some point, the bubble will burst. Harrison Butker will recover from his injury and will return to the Kansas City Chiefs active roster. He'll resume his duties as the team's kicker and that will leave Spencer Shrader on the outside looking in on the Chiefs' active roster.
Kansas City Chiefs kicker Spencer Shrader opened up about his decision to choose the team over the New York Jets. Shrader, who was signed by the Chiefs off the Jets' practice squad after Harrison Butker’s knee injury, revealed his excitement about being part of a top-tier team.
In yet another game this season, the Kansas City Chiefs needed some late-outing heroics to bring home a win. Luckily for them, that arrived in the form of a game-winning field goal as time expired on Sunday against the Carolina Panthers.
And just like that, the Spencer Shrader era comes to an end. The place kicker who went 2-2 on field goals for Gang Green has been snapped up by the Kansas City Chiefs.
The Colts announced on Monday that they have signed K Spencer Shrader to their practice squad. Shrader, 25, signed with Indianapolis as an UDFA out of Notre Dame following the 2024 NFL Draft.
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
Free Newsletters

